
If your lock still works, is in good condition and the only problem is who holds a key, you can usually retrofit or rekey it and keep the hardware. If the lock is worn, damaged, out of step with your insurer’s requirements or simply weaker than the door deserves, replace it. A locksmith decides this by looking at the lock and the door together, and our team at ECS Locksmiths does that on site across Dublin, for homes, pubs, restaurants, offices and vehicles.
The terms are used loosely, so here are the three options in plain words:
Inside a lock cylinder, small pins or wafers match the cuts on your key. Rekeying means the locksmith removes those components and resets them to a new pattern. Nobody holding an old copy can open the door. The lock itself is unchanged, so rekeying suits a lock that is in good working order and already of a decent standard.
It is the right response to a defined problem: keys you cannot account for, a tenant who has moved out, a member of staff who has left. Our guides on rekeying locks after an employee leaves and on what to do when a tenant loses keys go through those situations in detail.
Retrofitting is the middle path. Typical examples:
The benefit is less disruption and no need to refit or repaint the door. We cover the electronic side in our guide to choosing retrofit or full replacement for electronic locks, and the fit questions in smart lock installation in Ireland.
Replacement removes the old lock entirely. It is the answer when the lock is damaged by a break-in attempt, worn so that the key sticks or turns loosely, or when you want a different type of lock altogether, such as moving from a basic latch to a high-security mortice or from a single to a double cylinder. Our guide to single versus double cylinder locks explains that choice.
Work through these questions in order. The first “yes” in the replace column usually settles it.
| Question | Points to retrofit or rekey | Points to replace |
|---|---|---|
| What is the lock’s condition? | Turns smoothly, no damage, no play in the handle | Sticking, worn, bent, forced or visibly damaged |
| What is the problem? | Key control: lost, stolen or unreturned keys | Security level: the lock is weaker than the door’s risk |
| How old is the hardware? | Recent and sound | Old enough that parts are failing |
| Does it fit what you need? | Same function, new keys | You want a different function, such as smart or access control |
| How many doors? | A few doors on one key system | Mixed old locks that no one can match up |
The PSA’s consumer guidance for homeowners is clear on the starting point: if you cannot account for all the keys to your front door, consider the security risk and think about changing your lock. The same page cites Garda statistics that 55% of burglars enter through the front or back door, which is why the lock on those two doors deserves the attention.
If the door looks tired but works, a refresh may be all you need. For a uPVC door, for example, spraying a uPVC door can restore the finish without replacing the door, and the lock work can then be done separately to the right level.
This is where Irish readers differ from the generic advice that tops search results. Three points matter.
Locksmiths must be licensed. Since 1 February 2017, all contractors providing locksmith services in Ireland need a PSA licence. The Private Security (Licensing and Standards) Regulations 2023 define a locksmith broadly: someone who installs, opens, maintains, repairs or services locking devices for premises or motor vehicles, including duplicating restricted keys, safe keys or transponder keys. So rekeying, retrofitting and replacing all fall under licensed work. The PSA’s 2024 annual report records 203 contractor licences in the locksmith sector at the end of 2024 and 1,642 unannounced inspections that year, so enforcement is active.

Replacements must not lower your security. The PSA’s standard for locksmiths, PSA 55:2022, requires that replaced locks are of the same or an increased level of security as the original, unless the client asks for a lower level in writing. In practice, a licensed locksmith will not simply fit the cheapest lock to a door that had a better one.
Master key systems need written authorisation. The same standard says locksmiths must not repair, service, modify or expand keys or cylinders in a master key system without the client’s written authorisation, with the implications explained in advance. If you manage a building where one master key opens many doors, any rekey or retrofit has to be agreed in writing first.
If you run a pub, restaurant, shop or office, the final exit doors are a separate matter. PSA guidance on building regulations says that where a repair or replacement is carried out on an existing final exit door already fitted with a thumb-turn lock, at least a thumb-turn must be used, and replacement locks must be of equivalent or better compliance. A repair must not leave the door in greater breach of the regulations. Whatever you retrofit, people must still be able to leave quickly. We fit panic bars and emergency exit devices, and we work with this in mind on every commercial exit door.
For most Dublin homes, the front and back doors are the focus. If keys are the issue and the lock is sound, rekeying gets you back to a clean slate the same day. If the lock is a basic one, or you are fitting a new door, replace it with a higher-security lock. On a uPVC or composite door, the cylinder is often the weak point, so a cylinder upgrade is the classic retrofit: the door stays, the vulnerable part changes.
If you have lost your keys outright, speed matters more than the rekey-or-replace question at first. Our guide on lost house keys explains why the first 20 to 30 minutes count. After you are back inside, we look at the lock and tell you whether it needs rekeying or replacing.
Business premises have more keyholders and more turnover. Every time a manager, chef or bar worker leaves, you face the same question: do the keys come back, and can you be certain no copy exists? Rekeying is the fast, low-disruption answer on doors with good locks. Where many staff need access at different times, a retrofit to access control removes the problem of key copies altogether, because a card or code can be cancelled in seconds. We install access control systems and master key systems for exactly this.
Closing time and deliveries also mean doors are used heavily. Heavy use wears locks faster, so a lock that was fine five years ago may be a candidate for replacement now.
With several units, the decision is about consistency. Do you need every door on one key system? Do you need to cut off a previous occupant quickly and cheaply? A sensible approach:
A mix of rekeying and replacing within one building is normal and often the most economical route.
Car keys are a different story. Modern keys carry transponder chips, remote fobs or proximity sensors, and the vehicle’s immobiliser recognises them. An Post Insurance says replacing a modern car key in Ireland can cost anywhere from €150 to over €500, depending on make and model, with the chip, fob and proximity types the dearest. Its Keycare cover, as published, costs €19.76 a year including levy and covers replacement keys, fobs, immobiliser and reprogramming up to a combined €1,500 a year when no duplicate exists. That is a reason to have a spare cut and programmed before you lose the only one.
Our automotive service covers car lockout assistance, standard and transponder key replacement, remote key fob programming and ignition repair and replacement. With a car, “rekey versus replace” usually comes down to this: if the ignition or lock is damaged, replace it; if you only need a new or extra key, a cut and programmed key is the fix.

There is no honest flat price for “retrofit versus replace”, because the cost depends on the lock type, the number of doors, the security level you choose and the time of day. A few principles hold:
We give free estimates, so you can see what each route would cost for your door before you decide.
Whoever you hire, ask these:
A reputable locksmith answers all of these without hesitation.
We cover residential, commercial and automotive work in Dublin, 24/7, with free estimates and a customer satisfaction guarantee. That includes rekeying, lock installation and repair, key cutting and duplication, lock upgrades, high-security lock installation, smart lock installation, master key systems and access control. If you are not sure whether your lock needs a retrofit or a replacement, we look at the lock and the door and give you a clear recommendation. See the full list on our services page, or find your area through our Dublin locksmith page.

Most callers ask us the same thing: “Do I need a whole new lock?” Often the honest answer is no, because the lock is sound and the real problem is who has a key. In that case, rekeying or a cylinder upgrade solves it quickly, with little disruption to your door.
But we also see the other side. A good lock on a weak door, or a basic lock guarding a busy pub’s back door, is a risk that a new key will not fix. When we say replace, it is because the door’s risk and the lock’s level no longer match, and we would rather you were secure than merely re-keyed.
Our approach is to look at the lock, the door, the people who use it and the rules that apply, then tell you which route fits. Rekey, retrofit or replace, the work is done by licensed locksmiths, and the new lock never drops below the security level of the old one.
Barry
Rekeying makes your old keys useless, which solves a key control problem. It does not raise the security level of the lock. If the lock is a good one in good condition, it is as secure as it was before; if it is basic or worn, replacing it gives you a stronger lock.
Most standard cylinders can be, but not all, and a damaged or very worn lock is better replaced. A locksmith needs to see the lock to tell. Some locks, such as certain car ignitions or older mechanisms, may call for a new part or a newly cut key instead.
Yes. Since 1 February 2017, contractors providing locksmith services in Ireland need a PSA licence. This applies to work on homes, commercial premises and motor vehicles, so ask to see the licence before work starts.
Yes, if you cannot account for every key. The PSA advises considering changing the lock when you cannot account for all keys to the front door. Rekeying is usually enough when the existing lock is in good condition.
Contact a locksmith who handles automotive keys and can cut and programme a replacement. Car keys with chips or fobs can be costly, which is why many owners have a spare made while they still hold a working key.
It’s more than just unlocking doors. Most locksmiths provide:
Emergency lockouts (home, car, business)
Lock repairs and replacements
Key cutting and rekeying
Security upgrades (e.g. anti-snap locks)
Car key replacement
In emergency situations, typical arrival times should be at your location within 20-30 minutes. There are always professional locksmiths on standby, ready to handle any lockout or security emergency, ensuring safety is never compromised.
Absolutely! Most locksmiths specialise in advanced high-security lock systems, including electronic locks, biometric security, smart locks, and keyless entry systems. The should be trained in the latest security technologies, ensuring that they can provide the highest level of protection for your home, office, or vehicle. Ask for a free expert consultation to help you choose the right security system for your needs.
Yes, all locksmiths should stand by the quality of there work and offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee. Most would by default offer a warranty on all services, ensuring that you receive the best craftsmanship and long-lasting results.
Yes, most locksmiths are trained to open cars.
Most locksmiths in Ireland offer 24/7 emergency callouts and typically arrive within 15–60 minutes, depending on your location and traffic. In Dublin, response times can be as fast as 10–30 minutes, especially for emergency lockouts.
Yes A professional locksmiths use non-destructive entry methods first. Drilling is usually a last resort, not the default approach.
If someone immediately suggests drilling without inspecting the lock, that’s a red flag.
Costs vary depending on the service, time of day, and complexity of the job. A standard lockout is usually cheaper than replacing a lock. Emergency or late-night services may cost more.
Prices vary, but here’s a realistic guide:
Standard callout/labour: €85–€95
Lockout service: from ~€85–€120+
Lock replacement: depends on parts + labour
Important: Always ask for a full quote upfront and if there is a call out fee. Some companies advertise low prices but increase costs after arriving.
Prices can vary quite a bit… call around for quotes!
Yes A professional locksmiths use non-destructive methods whenever possible. Damage usually only happens if the lock is faulty, high-security, or has already been tampered with.
Yes. In Ireland, all locksmiths must be licensed by the Private Security Authority (PSA).
If you’re hiring someone:
Ask for their PSA licence number
Avoid anyone who can’t prove credentials
By asking for the licence you avoid the scammers.

Providing Locksmith Services For More Than 30 Years in Dublin, lock outs, lock fitting, slam locks, car opening, commerical and domestic.
Home
About Us
Services
Testimonial
Faqs
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions